Steven Moffat On The Doctorless Anniversary Special That Never Was

We’ve previously been told what a plate spinning act the 50th anniversary special, The Day of the Doctor was for showrunner Steven Moffat but, in the latest issue of Doctor Who Magazine, the soon departing writer lays down not one, not two, but three different versions – one with absolutely no Doctors at all!

Laying down his initial plans following an arduous Season 7a and 7b, Moffat told DWM:

“The Name of the Doctor, the original version, ends with Matt’s Doctor walking into his time-stream after he’s kissed River, and I didn’t know what was going to come after that, but I knew that it’d leap us into the 50th, even though I didn’t know what the 50th was going to be.

At one point, I thought Matt’s Doctor was going to step into his time-stream… and wake up as Christopher Eccleston. The Moment, who wasn’t Billie Piper at that point, would say, ‘So what do you think?’ He’d say, ‘What do you mean? What do I think about what?’ She’d say, ‘That’s what would happen.’”

So like Dallas (which Moffat denies ever having seen) large chucks of continuity would be deemed non-canonical in one fell swoop or in Dallas’ shoulder pad clad vision, one fell shower.

DWM502_COVER_with bag

Moffat goes on to explain that it would only have been a temporary move with the Doctor reinstating the timeline as we know it, adding, ‘Matt and David would have turned up like the Ghosts of Christmas Future’.

However, that’s not the only alternative he briefly flirted with:

“There was another version – which was on paper for a while – where Matt’s Doctor walks into his time-stream and onto a battlefield, and finds Chris with the big, red button, about to press it…”

That’s definitely not a big friendly button…but again, Moffat hurdle that potential future into the waste paper basket.

Then there was the version that we’ve all heard about, which, quite frankly sounds like televised suicide for the show when, for the show’s big anniversary, there were no Doctors in the episode at all.

Clara_Oswald_The_Day_of_The_Doctor

Thanks to some behind the scenes shenanigans there were absolute no Doctors under contract. But, having to work with literally nothing but Clara (Jenna Coleman being the only actor under contract at the time) and a theme tune, Moffat concocted a Doctor Who episode all about the absence of the Doctor.

After the Doctor walked into his own Time Stream in The Name of the Doctor he would have deleted his own existence, leaving Clara to save the day. The companion would recognise him in stories and movies, played by various famous actors, and this would enable her to regain her memory to bring him back.

Moffat said:

“But the idea was that we’d have lots of people playing the Doctor. That version of the Anniversary Special existed in my head for about a day. That was just me being slightly hysterical, I think. Because I was hysterical.

But The Day of the Doctor worked out. I thought.”

You can read the full interview in Doctor Who Magazine 502 which is on sale now from all good stockist.

  • TimeChaser

    You definitely can’t have a Doctorless 50th, as interesting as the story might have been. I doubt fans would have been happy with that.

    I’m glad they went with what they did in the end. I think we got the best possible outcome (and finally an answer to all those teasers about the Doctor and Elizabeth I).

  • Dr. Moo

    TBH all of these ideas lack the essential spark of a good story. What we got was one of the high points of the show, new and classic alike, with a truly wonderful celebration. Two companions, Daleks, Time Lords, Zygons, UNIT, a regeneration, Gallifrey saved and fourteen (“The Curator” counts) Doctors! Nobody in their right mind could’ve asked for more.

  • Ranger

    Yep, glad the 50th turned out the way it did, though the concept of a Doctorless show is intriguing. But it would have led to so much negativity that it would have made a fiasco of the celebrations.

  • Philip

    “At one point, I thought Matt’s Doctor was going to step into his time-stream… and wake up as Christopher Eccleston. The Moment, who wasn’t Billie Piper at that point, would say, ‘So what do you think?’ He’d say, ‘What do you mean? What do I think about what?’ She’d say, ‘That’s what would happen.’”” – Oh I LOVE that idea. That’s inspired.