The Doctor Who Companion

Get your daily fix of news, reviews, and features with the Doctor Who Companion!

7 Rubbish Things About Trial of a Time Lord

Poor Colin Baker. His tenure as the Sixth Doctor was a troubled time for the show, and as such, Trial of a Time Lord was his last series, following a hiatus which made fans blow several gaskets. If Twitter had been around in the 1980s, it would’ve consisted mainly of capital letters.
Let’s face it: Doctor Who can sometimes be a bit pants, and Trial of a Time Lord is no exception. If this feels too negative for the DWC, come back tomorrow because we’ll be looking at what really worked for the season.
But for now, drag your heels as we revisit this 14-part epic…

The Mysterious Planet

For several years before actually watching Trial of a Time Lord, I was under the impression that this four-part opener was generally considered the best section of the Doctor’s court room drama. Once I saw The Mysterious Planet, this didn’t bode well for the rest of the season. Because apart from the stuff on the space station, it’s a mess.
The idea is there, but the execution begs to be executed.
We’re used to the Doctor running up and down corridors, but these are dark ones – especially the underground station bit, trying to be reminiscent of The Web of Fear; instead ending up like spending a tube journey where the power goes off and you end up with the local nutter chatting to you about aliens stealing the planet.
This is Doctor Who, so robots bumble about and just aren’t functional. For anyone living in the West country, the one in question – Drathro – will bring on nightmares of watching Jethro. Ooh-arr.

The Valeyard

Michael Jayston played him beautifully, but the Valeyard is an utter mess.
What is he supposed to be? You get uncertain terms, mutterings about him being the dark persona of the Doctor, somewhere between his twelfth and final incarnations. What does that mean, exactly? The Doctor is dark anyway: he can be careless, irresponsible, and darn right threatening. He murders and he fashions others into murderers too. What does the Valeyard do that makes him so much worse?
I can forgive all that because he is an interesting idea, and as I say, he’s portrayed brilliantly. The thing I can’t get over is how the internet fandom had adopted him.
Whenever regeneration is mentioned, someone pipes up, “maybe this is where the Valeyard comes from” or “we’ll probably see the Valeyard again when the Doctor changes”. However you feel about him, we likely won’t see him again. I place the same odds on the return of the Chumblies, the Rani, and the Macra – oh no, wait, not that last one…


Vengeance on Varos isn’t half as blindingly brilliant as some will have you believe, desite being filled with glorious ideas and wonderful visuals. It’s far from bad, but equally, its pace is too slow to be considered an instant masterpiece.
The one thing that did work well was Sil the Mentor. Bringing him back for Mindwarp should’ve been great, and he is. So too is Kiv, an elder Mentor who Sil gets to grovel to. Lovely. Except there’s this nutty brain-swapping procedure. Peri gets her head shaved for… reasons. Nonetheless, that part of it works.
What doesn’t is – well, all the rest. Much as I love Brian Blessed, I just don’t get him or his werewolf pal. It’s like a pantomime where the tone jumps one way to the other. It doesn’t help that it’s another serial about running down dark metal corridors, just as The Mysterious Planet was.

Its Structure

There are good ideas hidden away in Trial of a Time Lord, but they don’t quite work because its structure is too strange. Its ambition was something akin to the Key to Time season, but expanding the last episode of The War Games (essentially) and basically referencing the real-life turbulence rocking the series was a mistake.
Still, if they pulled off telling three stories of past, present, and future well, it could’ve worked – even with the odd amendment that is The Ultimate Foe.
It makes for a season where no one quite knows what’s real and what’s not, where death doesn’t always mean death, where the Doctor soon gets over the supposed demise of Peri because the story dictates he moves onto Mel.
To Time Lords, “past, present, and future” is a messy thing. The attempt is solid, especially being introduced to Mel before the Doctor meets her. But because of The Mysterious Planet, we never get a “past” instalment – this should’ve been a serial set in a recognised era of history, but instead, the concept never gets going.

Terror of the Vervoids

A murder mystery in space should work… and it largely does. I’m not sure the mystery elements fully pull off their potential (you don’t have to be an Agatha Christie enthusiast to suspect the wrongdoers); still, that’s the part that works best for Terror of the Vervoids.
Whether you think the Vervoids look rude or not, they’re not the worst part of this serial either. Nor is the courtroom sections, which here start to really drag; nor the Doctor’s defence making no sense whatsoever. What’s the worst thing? You might say, “Mel”, but she’s pretty good here.
No, the worst thing is some of the dialogue and the narrative plot holes/chasms that stop this from being remembered as a solid classic and the best part of Trial of a Time Lord.
You can see Pip and Jane Baker were trying for humour – “Whoever’s been dumped in there has been pulverised into fragments and sent floating into space, and in my book, that’s murder” – but it was a stumbling approach that doesn’t pay off.
Although, when the Valeyard says, “Are we to be subjected to more chicanery, Sagacity?”, I can’t help but recall Donna saying “I like the cut of your jib, chin-chin!” in The Unicorn and the Wasp. Fitting, don’t you think?


Even if you’re not Chris Chibnall and you actively enjoy Trial of a Time Lord, it’s tinged with sadness, for two reasons.
The first is that it’s Colin Baker’s last story as the Sixth Doctor. We all know he shouldn’t have taken the blame for the show’s dwindling reputation; it was far more complicated than that, and Baker was the scapegoat. He felt so irked – rightly so, I might add – that he refused to return for his regeneration scene: now that The Night of the Doctor and The Day of the Doctor have both come and gone, he’s the only incarnation of the Doctor not to film his passing over the reins. It’s said that all humans wear a curly wig at some point in their life, and it was time for Sylvester McCoy to follow that rite of passage.
The second “last” is even more upsetting (no disrespect to Colin). The Ultimate Foe is the last work of the great Robert Holmes.
In 1986, Holmes grew seriously ill, and though he wrote The Mysterious Planet for the season (and he was due to contribute Yellow Fever, and How To Cure It for Season 23), he passed away before he could complete his script for The Ultimate Foe.
With that, we lost one of the best TV writers of all time.

The Ultimate Foe

Holmes wrote some truly stellar Doctor Who: Spearhead from Space; The Ark in Space; The Brain of Morbius; The Caves of Androzani, to name but a few. The Ultimate Foe is far from his strongest achievement.
It’s not fair, either, to solely blame Pip and Jane Baker, who completed the story. But it’s trying to be a sequel to The Deadly Assassin, and any story attempting that is doomed to fail – even with Holmes the original creative driving force.
It’s an exploration of the Matrix Databank, a place most people don’t really understand anyway, which can look like pretty much anything. It’s a bit of a mess, but it could’ve been so much stronger.
The original ending, for instance, would’ve been cooler, and solved the problem of the Sixth Doctor’s regeneration: it would’ve had the Doctor and Valeyard trapped in a final struggle to the death. Lovely. A bit downbeat? Yes, okay, but this was a downbeat time for the show.
It was certainly preferable to “carrot juice, carrot juice, carrot juice”…
We end on a downbeat tone. But this is the DWC, so come back tomorrow: we’ll be looking at 7 fantastic things about Trial of a Time Lord.

Philip Bates

Editor and co-founder of the Doctor Who Companion. When he’s not watching television, reading books ‘n’ Marvel comics, listening to The Killers, and obsessing over script ideas, Philip Bates pretends to be a freelance writer. He enjoys collecting everything.

31 thoughts on “7 Rubbish Things About Trial of a Time Lord

  1. For me the Vervoids is the best part of the series, but then I love a good murder mystery set in a posh, contained space! There is a lot wrong with Trial and I have to say that I don’t watch the entire season very often, mostly just going to Vervoids if I’m in the mood for some Colin. I was never a big fan of Peri and much as I love Brian Blessed he was not right for this part and so I tend to skip over this story and it is a long time since I last watched it. Perhaps I should go and watch it again to refresh my memory. I think my biggest problem with Trial is that there is no real goodbye to Peri or introduction of Mel (I’m not a Bonnie hater, like some fans) and I thought she was an adequate companion, probably not in my top 10, but I think she suffered from not having a true introductory story that might have gained her some sympathy from the audience. However, she has just presented, fully-formed as were, no explanation and I found it hard at first to get a grip on her character and why she did things.

    1. Try Big Finish Ranger; it has the time to fill the gaps in tremendously honouring and satisfying ways. Peri improves a lot, Mel too – her Juggernaughts role is very grown up. Plus you get a proper end for Sixie, and (someone will correct me if I’m wrong) a start for Mel.

      1. I keep thinking I must start to get into Big Finish, but I’m not really an audible book or radio person so it doesn’t draw me. I know that there are a lot of fans of this variant though and I think I am missing out, so I will give it a go at some point.
        And because Moo is a big list fan and so he can disagree with me, here are my top 10 companions:
        =1. Bill
        =1. Donna
        =3 Ace
        =3 Sarah Jane
        5 Turlough (I know, I know, but I JUST LOVE THE OVER-THE-TOP ACTING! It makes me laugh. Plus seeing how many times he can button and unbutton his jacket and look shiftily behind him in one scene)
        6 Jamie
        7 Harry
        8 Ian
        9 Jack
        10 Jo

        1. Ooh, I love a list!
          1. Donna
          2. Sarah-Jane
          3. Harry
          4. Ace
          5. Rose
          6. Peri
          7. Ian/Barbara (sorry, but I count them together as one)
          8. Jamie
          9. Jo
          10. K-9
          And honourable mentions go out to The Brig, Benton and yates.

          1. I debated long and hard about the Brig, but couldn’t quite bring myself to treat him as an official companion. But if I did, he would be the undisputed, leading by a gazillion points from anyone else, no. 1

          1. Turlough is, in my humble opinion, the best companion of the fifth Doctor’s era.

          2. I would agree, but that’s more of a critique of his other companions than a glowing commendation of Turlough. He’s not just the best one, he’s the only good one!

          3. Well, Turlough despite his faults, at least he had *some* kind of logical plan to destroy the Doctor, unlike the Valeyard. 😀

        2. What I like about Turlough is his habit of looking at the camera whenever he is about to exit a scene or go through a door

          1. Watch (for example) Resurrection of the Daleks with the commentary. Peter Davison & Janet Fielding both comment on it. The others might too.

          2. Right. Got builders in at the moment, and all the dvds are stacked in boxes in the garage, but when (when! I feel like it’s never going to happen) we get straight again Resurrection it is and a good bit of Turlough watching.

        3. * loud explosions, smoke, lightening, trumpet fanfare *
          Hey there Ranger, somebody order a cow?
          Sorry. Do so love to make an entrance.
          Ah yes, a top ten companion list. I have trouble with just a top ten, but I’ll play. Let’s see……
          1. The Brig
          2. Donna
          3. Evelyn
          4. Charley
          5. Ian & Barbara (I’m cheating, accept it, but these come as a package)
          6. Clara
          7. Amy & Rory (see number five)
          8. K9
          9. Liv & Helen (three for three)
          10. Sarah

          1. Honourable mentions for Ace, Turlough, Steven, Vicki, Jamie, Zoe, Hex, Benny, Bill, Nardole.

          2. lol! and a spectacular entry you do make.
            See, I’m not that keen on Barbara, so I can separate them.

          3. My list is always changing, any one or all of those honourable mentions I gave in my other comment could make the list if I were doing it even now.

  2. The constant cutting back to the court room scenes gets really tedious after a while, the Doctor isn’t the only one who “wants to get on with it!”

  3. The Trial of a Time-Lord theme – kind of smacked of desperation because it felt like an also ran idea on a couple levels and because the idea wasn’t really thought through—JNT? That’s why it fails on several levels.
    Mysterious Planet – you could tell something was wrong with Holmes but I think by this point he was slaved to what JNT and Saward were trying to construct.
    Mindwarp – There was so many explosive personalities and bizarre goings on, the Doctor, Bald British Peri, Sil, Kiv, Ykanos, Dog guy, it was a bit insane and I say it compensates for any flaws. It’s my favorite of the series.
    Terror of the Vervoids – I’ve always struggled to stay awake watching that one. Maybe the best example of the JNT era of over-lighting a set. Mel barges in on us and you feel a bit assaulted because where the hell did she come from with that voice. face. Hair. Outfit. Etc. Guh.
    Ultimate Foe – I can’t blame Holmes for this as A) he was sick, B) still slaving under the guidelines of JNT/Sawards over all story and C) the Bakers were similarly clueless.
    I totally agree that the original ending would have been preferable. You’d think the Beeb would have had at least the decency to give Colin a proper send off adventure to kick off season 24, make it worthwhile for him to come back.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

7 Rubbish Things About Trial of a Time Lord

by Philip Bates time to read: 6 min
%d bloggers like this: